I recently tested the Bobbi Brown black gel eyeliner I'd used for a long time (MSRP $23) against the super cheap version created by e.l.f (MSRP $3). Check out my results below and let me know what you think! What type of gel eyeliner do YOU use?
SPLURGE
Bobbi Brown Long Wear Gel Eyeliner in Jet Black
$23, Sephora
Pros: easy to apply, creates opaque effect with one coat, makes thick line styles with ease
Cons: smudges when touched and while drying (can leave marks on upper lid just after application which easily wipe off), clots on brush - you need to clean/replace brushes regularly (brush NOT included), thickness makes it somewhat hard to create thin line styles, pricey!
STEAL
e.l.f. Studio Cream Eyeliner in Black
$3, e.l.f.
Pros: doesn't smudge, includes a slanted eyeliner brush in every package, easy to apply in thin lines, overall great value!
Cons: a little bit thinner than other eyeliners, may require two coats to achieve opaque effect